This is the second part to appear, but it's what originally got me thinking about the possibility of differences in the reactions to income and wealth inequality, so I'm calling it part 1. In recent years, popular evaluations of economic conditions have been very negative, even when the standard economic statistics are pretty good. This seems to have started in the Biden administration, and it's continued in the second Trump administration. Many people say this is because of inflation--people dislike price increases, and maybe even want prices to fall. I don't find this convincing--if people were that averse to inflation, Nixon and Reagan would never have been re-elected. And if the issue is changes in inflation, evaluations should have been getting more positive in the last few years. So I started thinking about perceptions of changes in the distribution as an alternative--if people think that any gains are going to rich people, they will be discontented. There aren't that many questions about perceived changes in inequality, but Pew has occasionally asked about expectations of the next few decades: whether you think that the gap between rich and poor will become larger or smaller. They also have a question about whether you expect the American economy to become stronger or weaker over the same time frame. The figure shows summary measures (%larger-% smaller and %stronger-%weaker) for the questions:
In 2018 and 2023, people were more pessimistic about the gap between rich and poor and about the future of the economy than they had been in 1999 or 2010. The future of the economy question was asked again in 2026 and people were more favorable then they had been in 2023, but less favorable than they'd been in the 1990s or even in 2010. With only a few observations, you can't get strong statistical evidence for anything, but for what it's worth the correlation between expectations about the gap and the strength of the economy is -.79: when people expected the gap to increase, they were more likely to think that the economy would become weaker. That raises the question of why people became more likely to think that the gap between rich and poor would increase, which led to my previous post.
[Data from the Roper Center for Public Opinion Research]







